2022 Honda Civic vs 2022 Opel Astra
The 2022 Honda Civic and 2022 Opel Astra (known as Vauxhall Astra in the UK) are both compact family hatchbacks popular in the European market, targeting buyers seeking a blend of efficiency, practicality, and modern features. The Civic, particularly in its e:HEV hybrid form, emphasizes strong performance and Honda's renowned reliability, while the Astra stands out for its stylish design, competitive pricing, and improved build quality under Stellantis ownership. They are commonly compared due to their positioning in the C-segment against rivals like the VW Golf and Ford Focus, with group tests highlighting the Civic's dynamic edge and the Astra's value and comfort.
Detaljno poređenje
| Kategorija | Honda Civic | Opel Astra | Pobjednik |
|---|---|---|---|
| Performance | Honda Civic e:HEV Sport offers 181bhp from a 2.0-litre hybrid, achieving 0-62mph in 7.9 seconds with lively response in Sport mode. | Opel Astra's larger engines provide matching 0-62mph times around 7.9 seconds, feeling responsive with electric motor assistance but less refined than the Civic. | A |
| Comfort | Civic provides solid comfort but noted for cheaper-feeling details like halogen reversing lights. | Astra excels in comfort, practicality, and solid build, praised in tests for its relaxing ride. | B |
| Technology | Civic features modern hybrid tech and efficient powertrain, though specific infotainment details are less highlighted. | Astra integrates cutting-edge tech with versatile powertrains, setting benchmarks in innovation. | B |
| Safety | Civic untested by Euro NCAP at launch but expected strong based on prior models. | Astra earned 4 stars under tougher 2022 standards, competitive despite not reaching 5 stars. | Neriješeno |
| Practicality | Civic has 60/40 split-folding seats, good space but less versatile than rivals. | Astra matches with 60/40 seats plus ski hatch, noted for practicality in tests. | B |
| Running Costs | Civic achieves 50.3mpg, costing £2,999 for 20,000 miles, cheapest in tests. | Astra at under £3,500 for 20,000 miles, higher but competitive with efficient options. | A |
| Resale Value | Honda's strong reputation supports better retention. | Astra decent but trails Japanese rivals due to brand perception. | A |
Prednosti
2022 Honda Civic
Excellent hybrid efficiency and low running costs
Strong performance and lively handling
Proven Honda reliability
Cheaper insurance on used models
2022 Opel Astra
Competitive pricing and value
Superior comfort and build quality
Innovative technology and design
Good practicality with ski hatch
Nedostaci
2022 Honda Civic
Higher initial purchase price
Some cheaper interior details
Untested by Euro NCAP at launch
More expensive used compared to Astra equivalents
2022 Opel Astra
Higher running costs than Civic
Questionable long-term reliability vs Honda
4-star safety rating
Turbo engines raise concerns in owner forums
Poređenje cijena
Honda Civic
€32,500 - €47,000
Opel Astra
€27,910 - €47,260
The Opel Astra starts lower at around €27,910, undercutting the Civic's €32,500 entry, offering better value for features. Astra's monthly operational costs are competitive, making it attractive for budget-conscious buyers, while Civic justifies premium with efficiency.
Pouzdanost
Honda Civic
Iznad prosjekaOpel Astra
Prosječno
Honda Civic benefits from strong reliability reputation, with naturally aspirated or later hybrid models avoiding major issues like oil dilution in turbos. Owner forums and experts favor Civic over Astra for longevity, especially vs turbocharged Vauxhall/Opel engines prone to concerns. Astra's newer platform shows promise but lacks Honda's proven track record.
Najbolje za
Honda Civic
Buyers prioritizing reliability, low running costs, and performance for mixed motorway/city driving, ideal for long-term ownership.
Opel Astra
Value seekers wanting comfort, tech, and style on a tighter budget, suited for those valuing practicality over ultimate dependability.
Konačna ocjena
Pobjednik: 2022 Honda Civic
The 2022 Honda Civic narrowly wins overall thanks to superior performance, efficiency, reliability, and resale value. The Opel Astra fights back strongly on price, comfort, and tech, making it a compelling value choice. Choose Civic for dependability, Astra for affordability.