2021 Honda Jazz vs 2021 Renault Captur
The Honda Jazz and Renault Captur represent two distinct approaches to the affordable family car segment in Europe. The Jazz is a practical hatchback known for its innovative interior space and reliability, while the Captur is a compact SUV offering a higher driving position and modern styling. Although they serve slightly different market segments—the Jazz as a versatile urban and family hatchback versus the Captur as a lifestyle SUV—they frequently compete for buyers seeking affordable, practical vehicles with good fuel economy and modern features. This comparison examines how these two popular models stack up across key performance, comfort, technology, safety, and practicality metrics to help European buyers make an informed decision.
Detaljna usporedba
| Kategorija | Honda Jazz | Renault Captur | Pobjednik |
|---|---|---|---|
| Performance | Honda Jazz equipped with a 1.2-litre or 1.5-litre engine producing 89-119 bhp with responsive handling characteristic of a hatchback platform. CVT and manual transmission options available. | Renault Captur offers a 1.2-litre TCE petrol engine with 115 bhp or a 1.8-litre E-Tech hybrid with 160 bhp. The hybrid variant significantly outperforms the petrol engine with better acceleration and smoother power delivery. | B |
| Comfort | Jazz scored 7.25/10 for comfort with manual air conditioning and limited climate control features. Interior space is well-optimized but not class-leading in terms of cabin amenities. | Captur scored 7.50/10 for comfort with automatic climate control, higher seating position typical of SUVs, and more premium interior appointments. However, reviewers note it is 'not that comfortable around town' despite modern features. | B |
| Technology | Jazz features basic infotainment with limited smartphone integration. Earlier model years lack advanced driver assistance systems and modern connectivity features. | Captur offers more comprehensive technology including a 10.4-inch touchscreen, available Google infotainment system on higher trims, steering-mounted audio controls, keyless entry, and push-button start. More advanced ADAS features available. | B |
| Safety | Jazz scored 8.00/10 for safety ratings. Features include AEB with pedestrian and cyclist detection, Forward Collision Warning, Lane Departure Warning, Lane Keep Assist, Blind Spot Warning, Rear Cross Traffic Alert, Traffic Sign Recognition, adaptive cruise control, and comprehensive parking sensors. | Captur scored 7.00/10 for safety ratings. Euro NCAP 2024 testing awarded 4/5 stars (downgraded from previous 5-star rating), with 76% adult occupant protection, 80% child protection, and 76% vulnerable road user protection. AEB functions between 10-80 km/h for cars/bikes/pedestrians and 7-170 km/h for moving vehicles. | A |
| Practicality | Jazz features innovative interior space management with compact exterior dimensions. Boot capacity allows for flexible configurations suitable for families and urban use. | Captur provides significantly superior practicality with 422-536L boot capacity (up 81 litres compared to previous generation) and extending to 1,275L with rear seats folded. Sliding rear seat moves forward 160mm, ideal for child seats. Flat 1.57-metre floor space with rear seats down provides exceptional versatility. | B |
| Running Costs | Jazz manual achieves 15 km/L (6.5L/100km combined), CVT variant manages approximately 17 km/L (5.9L/100km). Real-world testing showed 8.0L/100km manual and 8.2L/100km CVT. Insurance and maintenance costs are relatively low due to widespread reliability and parts availability. | Petrol variant (1.2 TCE 115) fuel economy comparable to Jazz. Hybrid E-Tech 1.8 achieves 64.2 mpg (Renault claim) with real-world testing confirming approximately 50 mpg under mixed conditions, even when heavily laden. Significantly lower CO2 emissions provide company car tax advantages and reduced first-year road tax. | B |
| Resale Value | Honda vehicles typically retain strong resale value due to brand reputation for reliability, widespread market demand, and established service networks across Europe. Jazz maintains consistent values in the used market. | Renault vehicles generally experience slightly weaker resale value retention compared to Japanese manufacturers like Honda. SUV market segment provides some support, but brand perception impacts depreciation curves. Hybrid variants may retain better value than petrol-only models. | A |
Prednosti
2021 Honda Jazz
Excellent safety feature set including AEB with pedestrian/cyclist detection, Lane Keep Assist, Blind Spot Warning, and adaptive cruise control
Strong resale value and brand reputation for reliability with established European service networks
Compact exterior dimensions with innovative interior space management ideal for urban driving and parking
2021 Renault Captur
Superior boot capacity (422-536L expanding to 1,275L) and innovative sliding rear seat for maximum versatility
Hybrid E-Tech engine option delivering 160 bhp with exceptional real-world fuel economy (approximately 50 mpg) and low CO2 emissions
Modern infotainment technology including Google integration, 10.4-inch touchscreen, keyless entry, and comprehensive driver assistance features
Nedostaci
2021 Honda Jazz
Limited infotainment technology with basic connectivity and older multimedia systems
Lower maximum power output compared to Captur hybrid (119 bhp versus 160 bhp)
Less spacious interior and smaller boot capacity limiting practicality for larger families
2021 Renault Captur
Euro NCAP 4-star rating (2024) represents downgrade from previous generation, though still adequate protection
Weaker resale value retention compared to Honda due to brand perception and market positioning
Noted as uncomfortable around town despite modern features, suggesting ride and handling characteristics may challenge urban drivers
Usporedba cijena
Honda Jazz
€15,000 - €22,000
Renault Captur
€16,500 - €24,000
The Honda Jazz typically undercuts the Renault Captur on purchase price, particularly when comparing equivalent trim levels and powertrains. A What Car Awards January 2024 assessment noted that 'the Clio undercuts most of its rivals on price—particularly the Jazz,' indicating competitive pricing pressure despite the Jazz's feature set. The Captur's higher starting price reflects its SUV positioning and advanced technology packages. However, the Captur hybrid's superior fuel economy and lower emissions can offset higher purchase costs through reduced running expenses and potential company car tax benefits for certain buyers over a five-year ownership period. For budget-conscious European buyers, the Jazz offers better immediate value, while the Captur represents better long-term value through operational savings with hybrid propulsion.
Pouzdanost
Honda Jazz
IzvrsnoRenault Captur
Iznad prosjeka
Honda vehicles, particularly the Jazz, demonstrate excellent reliability records across European markets with consistent performance in independent testing and owner forums. Honda's reputation for durability, proven engineering, and widespread parts availability support strong long-term reliability expectations. The Jazz specifically benefits from mature platform development and extensive real-world testing data confirming dependable operation. Renault Captur models show above-average reliability, though the brand does not command the same reputation for long-term durability as Honda. The Captur's dual-clutch and hybrid transmissions introduce slightly more complexity than the Jazz's simpler mechanical systems, potentially affecting long-term dependability. Real-world data from owner forums (Spritmonitor, ClubJazz) confirm the Jazz's consistent performance, while Captur owners report generally satisfactory experiences with modern powertrains requiring proper maintenance protocols.
Najbolje za
Honda Jazz
The Honda Jazz is ideal for urban drivers and families prioritizing reliability, strong resale value, and proven dependability over the latest technology. Buyers seeking a compact, easy-to-park vehicle with excellent safety features and lower purchase costs will find the Jazz compelling. It suits those who value brand heritage, established service networks, and long-term cost predictability. The Jazz appeals to conservative buyers wanting proven technology rather than cutting-edge features.
Renault Captur
The Renault Captur suits buyers prioritizing modern technology, spacious interiors, and SUV styling over outright value. Families needing maximum boot space and flexible seating configurations will appreciate the innovative sliding rear seat and generous cargo area. Buyers interested in hybrid powertrains for environmental considerations and company car tax benefits should strongly consider the E-Tech variant. The Captur appeals to those valuing contemporary infotainment, higher driving position, and modern design aesthetics despite slightly higher purchase costs and depreciation considerations.
Konačna ocjena
Previše blizu za odluku
Both vehicles excel in different areas without a clear overall victor. The Honda Jazz delivers superior reliability, safety features, resale value, and affordability, making it the logical choice for practical, budget-conscious European buyers prioritizing dependability. The Renault Captur counters with substantially superior practicality through innovative boot solutions, modern technology integration, and exceptional efficiency through its hybrid powertrain option, appealing to those valuing contemporary features and lifestyle positioning. Choose the Jazz for proven reliability and value retention; choose the Captur for space, technology, and operational efficiency. The decision ultimately depends on whether you prioritize reliability and cost-effectiveness (Jazz) or modern amenities and practical versatility (Captur).